

Imagine a university library completing a major book digitization project. After weeks of scanning, the service provider delivers hundreds of digital books, neatly arranged in folders and ready for the library’s collection. Everything appears complete until a researcher opens one of the files and discovers that several pages are missing. Another book contains blurred text, while a third has pages in the wrong order.
The books have been scanned, but are they truly ready for use?
This is one of the most important questions libraries, universities, museums and archives should ask before accepting completed digitization work. Scanning a book is only one part of the process. The real measure of success is whether the digital copy accurately represents the original and allows readers to access its contents without difficulty.
A proper quality review helps institutions identify errors before they approve a project, protecting both their investment and the value of their collections.
A digitised book should preserve the information and important visual details contained in the original. Readers should be able to follow the text, examine illustrations and move through the pages without encountering errors that interrupt their experience.
Poor scanning quality can make an otherwise valuable digital collection frustrating to use. A missing page could remove an important argument from a research publication, while an unclear illustration might prevent a student from understanding the information it presents.
For institutions preserving rare or fragile books, quality becomes even more important. Repeated scanning may expose delicate materials to unnecessary handling, so getting the process right the first time helps protect the originals.
Before approving any digitised book, institutions should review several essential aspects of the finished file.
The first step is to confirm that the digital book contains all the pages it should.
Compare the scanned copy with the original book or an accurate page inventory. Check the title page, table of contents, numbered pages, illustrations, appendices and any other material included in the agreed scanning scope.
Pay particular attention to pages that may have been skipped during scanning, especially where the original book contains blank pages, unnumbered sections or foldouts.
A digital book may appear complete at first glance, but missing pages can significantly reduce its usefulness.
Institutions should also confirm that the scanning team has not accidentally duplicated pages. The goal is to produce a complete and faithful digital representation of the original material.
A scanned page should allow readers to see the text comfortably without struggling to distinguish letters, numbers or punctuation.
Review pages with small print, faded ink, footnotes and tightly spaced text. These areas can reveal quality problems that may not appear on pages with larger, clearer lettering.
Blurred images, uneven lighting and excessive contrast can make important information difficult to read.
When evaluating image quality, avoid judging the entire book from only its first few pages. Examine samples from different sections, including pages with illustrations, tables and unusual layouts.
If the project has agreed image-quality specifications, use those requirements as the basis for approval rather than relying on appearance alone.
One common scanning problem occurs when part of a page falls outside the captured image.
Text near the binding may disappear, page numbers may be cut off, or illustrations may lose important details around their edges.
This is particularly common with tightly bound books that cannot open completely flat.
Check whether every page includes the information that appears in the original. The digital copy should preserve relevant content without cutting away text, annotations or other meaningful details.
Professional overhead book scanners, such as Bookeye, can help institutions capture bound materials while reducing the need to force books flat. However, operators must still position materials correctly and review the resulting images.
A book may contain every page and still provide a poor reading experience if the images appear crooked, curved or incorrectly positioned.
Look for pages that lean noticeably to one side, text that bends near the spine and images that appear stretched or distorted.
Also confirm that pages display in the correct orientation. Readers should not need to rotate individual pages repeatedly to follow the content.
Some professional scanning systems offer image-processing features that help correct page curvature, alignment and other capture issues. These tools can improve readability, but they do not eliminate the need for quality checks.
A good digital book should provide a consistent reading experience from beginning to end.
Not every book contains only text. Many include photographs, diagrams, maps, charts, handwritten notes and illustrations that carry important information.
When reviewing a digitised book, examine these elements carefully.
Check whether the scans preserve meaningful details, whether colours appear reasonably faithful to the original and whether important lines or labels remain visible.
For historical and archival collections, the appearance of the original material may have research value. Discolouration, annotations and other physical characteristics can sometimes provide useful context.
Institutions should therefore agree on the appropriate level of image fidelity before scanning begins.
The goal is not necessarily to make an old book look new, but to capture its contents accurately and preserve the details that matter.
A digitised book should follow the same logical sequence as the original.
Check that chapters appear in the right order, page sequences remain consistent and no sections have been misplaced during scanning or file assembly.
This is especially important for books with Roman numeral introductions, unnumbered pages, inserts or separate illustration sections.
An incorrect page sequence can confuse readers and make citations difficult to verify.
For larger projects, institutions can use page inventories and automated checks to identify potential sequencing errors, followed by manual review where necessary.
If your institution requested searchable digital books, checking the scanned images alone is not enough.
Optical Character Recognition (OCR) helps convert printed text into machine-readable information, allowing readers to search for words and phrases within a digital document.
Open the completed file and search for several words that appear on different pages. Check whether the search results lead to the correct locations and whether users can select or copy text where the agreed output supports those functions.
OCR accuracy can vary depending on print quality, language, typography and the condition of the original book.
Older publications, unusual fonts and faded pages may require additional review. Institutions should agree on realistic OCR requirements and any necessary correction work before approving the final files.
Even a perfectly scanned book becomes difficult to manage when the digital file has an unclear name or lacks important information.
Check whether the provider has followed the agreed file-naming structure and delivered the required formats, such as PDF, PDF/A or TIFF.
The institution should also review the metadata associated with each book. Relevant information may include the title, author, publication date, subject, edition and unique collection identifier.
Accurate metadata helps libraries organize their resources and makes it easier for readers to discover relevant materials.
For institutions using a digital archive system such as NAINUWA, consistent metadata and file organization can support the management and accessibility of completed digital collections.
Before signing off on a digitization project, open the completed books using the software or platform through which readers will access them.
Check whether the files open correctly, pages load properly and navigation works as expected. If the institution plans to provide online access, test the files within the intended digital library or archive environment.
For large projects, a risk-based review may combine automated checks, representative sampling and full inspection of books that present particular challenges. The institution should agree on acceptable error levels and correction procedures in advance.
If the review identifies missing pages, unreadable text or other significant problems, document the issues and request corrections before final acceptance.
A clear approval process helps both the institution and the service provider understand what constitutes a successfully completed book.
Producing reliable digital books requires suitable scanning equipment, careful handling and a consistent quality assurance process.
Eemediba provides Bookeye professional book scanners, ScanRobot automated book scanning solutions and professional digitization services to help libraries, universities and archives manage different types of book collections.
Bookeye solutions support the scanning of bound materials, while ScanRobot systems help institutions process suitable books in larger volumes through automated scanning workflows.
Eemediba also offers NAINUWA Digital Archive System to support the organization and management of completed digital collections.
By considering the condition of the original materials, the required output quality and how readers will use the finished files, institutions can establish a more reliable approach to book digitization.
Finishing the scanning process does not automatically mean a book is ready for a digital collection.
Libraries and institutions must confirm that the digital copy contains the complete content, preserves important details and provides a reliable reading experience.
A careful quality review can prevent missing information, reduce the need for repeated scanning and ensure that institutions receive the value they expect from their digitization projects.
The goal is not simply to approve a file because someone has scanned every page. It is to approve a digital book that readers can trust, researchers can use and future generations can continue to explore.